I'm using this blog to write about subjects related to the book, and to share additional material that didn't make it into the final edit.  I also plan to have guest bloggers from time to time. 

To subscribe:
Click here (works on most but not all browsers),
or go to http://blogtrottr.com/ and enter http://solarhousehistory.com/blog
or follow me on Twitter @tdenzer33

Link to list of All Blog Posts


Solar Orientation and Historic Buildings

When we look at plans of buildings, we are accustomed to two important conventions that indicate the building's orientation: the plan usually has a north-arrow; and north is usually "up," at the top of the page.  However, these are modern conventions, and so it's easy to be misled by looking at old drawings and inferring orientation at a glance. I was reminded of this issue recently while re-reading Dean Hawkes' excellent book Architecture and Climate: An Environmental History of British Architecture, 1600-2000.   

Here's an early engraving of the Chiswick House (London, 1725-29): 

Chiswick.jpg

You'd be forgiven if you assumed the front of the house faces south.  (The assumption is not only understandable for reasons of graphic convention, but also because we are now trained, to some extent, to assume 'wisdom' in the environmental strategies of pre-modern architects --- of course they wanted a south-facing porch.)

But as Hawkes mentions (almost parenthetically), the Chiswick House faces south-east.  I've rotated it to show how it might be better-portrayed for modern readers:

Chiswick 02.jpg

And Hawkes also noted that Chiswick's diagonal orientation was derived from Palladio's Villa Rotonda, although the "main entrance" at the Villa Rotonda faces northwest.  Is that a surprise?  (It surprised me ... and I've been there!)  Here is Palladio's canonical drawing: 

Palladio.jpg

The unconscious association of the graphic orthogonality with the cardinal points is amazingly powerful.  You project the drawing onto the world.  Now, here is a more 'accurate' representation of the plan:  

Palladio 02.jpg

To be clear, this is not to criticize the illustrators (Herisset and Palladio) for orienting their drawings in this manner, or the architects (Lord Burlington and Palladio) for the orientation of the buildings. 

Another famous example, I think, of a historic building with a misunderstood orientation is Hardwick Hall:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/25831000@N08/8049919893/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/25831000@N08/8049919893/

Hardwick Hall is sometimes cited as a forerunner of passive solar design.  This is the west facade however, not the south. 

Any others?  Please comment below! 

Related: Orientation of Le Corbusier's Unité d'Habitation